Builders' Forum |
|
↓ Scroll to Last Comment ↓ | Forum Guidelines | Builders' Forum | RSS |
i built a pax20 a few years back and im almost done with a shearwater s&g 17 im just curius to hear opinions about the differences between the two . i paddled the pax for about 3 years but found it was really too much of a racing boat for my usual type of paddling
3 replies:
RE: pax20 vs shearwater 17
Greg, I've been curious about seaworthiness of kayaks similar to that of the shearwater. I too have a Pax-20. In rough waters or just large wakes it tends to take water into the cockpit from the sides. I prefer not to wear a spray skirt in the warmer months because they are just too warm. I have a Georgian Bay by Laughing Loon with a 25" beam. It does great, but I want something in between the Pax and the really wide beam boats. I'm seriously considering a Spring Run or Return by Redfish. They are about the same as the Shearwater in size. You said you paddled in 25 knts winds. How did it do?
RE: pax20 vs shearwater 17
the boat did great in a cross wind i had it out in the ocean in about 3 foot chop and it handles great ive got a light nylon skirt thats fine .in boat wakes and breaking waves youll need a spray skirt in any kayak this one does have about double the free board of the pax so it wont be as necessary you could try to get a nylon spray skirt with a zipper i had one for the pax and it worked pretty good in the florida heat. im really STOKED about this boat and would highly recomend it !
RE: pax20 vs shearwater 17
» Submitted by greg27 - Wed, 12/3/08 » 8:41 PM
looks like i get to answer my own question.took the shearwater 17 out today for the first time and i loved it.so heres my 2cents lots of cockpit room .creature comfort seat was VERY comforatable . boat has excellent speed and takes very little effort to move along. if i was on flat water and paddling at a sprint pace the pax would be a little faster but for me i think any other situation i'll make better time in the shearwater.the shearwater feels very stable to me not at all"twitchy" ive only ever owned the pax and a couple SOTs none of those ever responded to edging but this boat really does its a nice feature and reallyu aids in steering a course .i was out in about 25mph winds in a small bay and while i didnt need it for those conditions im glad i put a skeg in it i think under worse conditions it would come in handy